A heated debate has emerged over whether or not the San Francisco 49ers ought to pay Brock Purdy, and one fan recommended they commerce up within the 2025 NFL Draft to pick out Shedeur Sanders. The concept has been closely criticized, with one analyst emphatically calling it “insanity.”
Might the 49ers Commerce Up for Shedeur Sanders?
One of many key arguments towards buying and selling up for Sanders is the presence of established quarterback Brock Purdy. Purdy, who led San Francisco to the Tremendous Bowl in 2024 and was an MVP finalist, has confronted ongoing skepticism regardless of his success.
Some Niners followers nonetheless query his skills and have floated the concept of bringing in a brand new quarterback, whereas analysts like Wealthy Eisen are vehemently towards it.
Eisen just lately addressed the commerce thought on his present, which was floated by considered one of his viewers who referred to as into this system; they recommended transferring Purdy to keep away from having to pay him, and as an alternative utilizing the picks to take Sanders.
Eisen, although, argued that transferring up within the draft to take an unproven rookie like Sanders could be an pointless gamble.
“You simply don’t need to go into the rookie quarterback mosh pit and hope they end up like Brock Purdy when you have already got Brock Purdy,” he stated.
One of many main considerations with taking a participant like Sanders is that he could be ranging from scratch within the NFL. Whereas he has proven expertise at Colorado beneath the teaching of his father, Deion Sanders, transitioning to the skilled stage is a special problem. The concept of paying a big worth in draft capital to safe an untested quarterback looks like an pointless threat when San Francisco already has a franchise quarterback.
Whereas Purdy struggled at instances final season, his stage of play all through his profession has been nothing wanting glorious. Accidents to key gamers like Trent Williams and Brandon Aiyuk affected the staff’s efficiency, making it unfair to position all of the blame on Purdy for San Francisco’s struggles.
These accidents, paired with Christian McCaffrey’s season-long damage points and Deebo Samuel Sr.’s struggles, resulted in a disappointing 12 months for the same old Tremendous Bowl contenders.
Quarterbacks Don’t Win Alone — It’s a Workforce Sport
The notion that an elite quarterback ought to have the ability to transcend staff weaknesses has been debated for years. Nevertheless, soccer stays a staff sport. Even with star quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes, staff assist is essential. Purdy’s critics overlook the impression of accidents and roster adjustments that affected the 49ers’ offense.
In the end, the argument towards buying and selling up for Sanders comes right down to practicality. Groups that have already got a succesful quarterback ought to give attention to strengthening different areas reasonably than playing on an unproven rookie. As Eisen put it, “Let’s not pay the man who took us to the Tremendous Bowl, however commerce up for a rookie? That’s insane.”
